There are three Fishing Creeks in York County. The northern Fishing Creek originates at Frogtown in Fairview Township and flows south-east until it joins the Susquehanna at Goldsboro.
| Name | AKA | Disposition | First Mill | Water Source | Township | Coordinates |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Prowell’s | Eichinger’s | Site | c1830 | Fishing Creek (N) | Fairview | 40.172982, -76.829008 |
| Jacob Bare’s | Prowell’s | Restaurant | 1835 | Fishing Creek (N) | Newberry | 40.159021, -76.816225 |
| Wentz’s | Wolfley’s | Site | 1750 | Big Spring Run | Newberry | 40.162303, -76.785002 |
| Goldsboro | Old Red Mill | Site | 1740 | Fishing Creek (N) | Newberry | 40.151376, -76.748714 |